- 📝 Posted:
- 🚚 Summary of:
- P0203, P0204
- ⌨ Commits:
4568bf7...86cdf5f
,86cdf5f...0c682b5
- 💰 Funded by:
- GhostRiderCog, [Anonymous], Yanga
- 🏷 Tags:
- rec98 th01 meta gameplay card-flipping player shot mod rng bomb waste
Let's start right with the milestones:
- More than 50% of all PC-98 Touhou game code has now been reverse-engineered! 🎉 While this number isn't equally distributed among the games, we've got one game very close to 100% and reverse-engineered most of the core features of two others. During the last 32 months of continuous funding, I've averaged an overall speed of 1.11% total RE per month. That looks like a decent prediction of how much more time it will take for 100% across all games – unless, of course, I'd get to work towards some of the non-RE goals in the meantime.
- 70 functions left in TH01, with less than 10,000 ASM instructions remaining! Due to immense hype, I've temporarily raised the cap by 50% until August 15. With the last TH01 pushes delivering at roughly 1.5× of the currently calculated average speed, that should be more than enough to get TH01 done – especially since I expect YuugenMagan to come with lots of redundant code. Therefore, please also request a secondary priority for these final TH01 RE contributions.
So, how did this card-flipping stage obstacle delivery get so horribly delayed? With all the different layouts showcased in the 28 card-flipping stages, you'd expect this to be among the more stable and bug-free parts of the codebase. Heck, with all stage objects being placed on a 32×32-pixel grid, this is the first TH01-related blog post this year that doesn't have to describe an alignment-related unblitting glitch!
That alone doesn't mean that this code is free from quirky behavior though, and we have to look no further than the first few lines of the collision handling for round bumpers to already find a whole lot of that. Simplified, they do the following:
pixel_t delta_y_between_orb_and_bumper = (orb.top - bumper.top); if(delta_y_between_orb_and_bumper <= 0) { orb.top = (bumper.top - 24); } else { orb.top = (bumper.top + 24); }
Immediately, you wonder why these assignments only exist for the Y
coordinate. Sure, hitting a bumper from the left or right side should happen
less often, but it's definitely possible. Is it really a good idea to warp
the Orb to the top or bottom edge of a bumper regardless?
What's more important though: The fact that these immediate assignments
exist at all. The game's regular Orb physics work by producing a Y velocity
from the single force acting on the Orb and a gravity factor, and are
completely independent of its current Y position. A bumper collision does
also apply a new force onto the Orb further down in the code, but these
assignments still bypass the physics system and are bound to have
some knock-on effect on the Orb's movement.
To observe that effect, we just have to enter Stage 18 on the 地獄/Jigoku route, where it's particularly trivial to reproduce. At a 📝 horizontal velocity of ±4, these assignments are exactly what can cause the Orb to endlessly bounce between two bumpers. As rudimentary as the Orb's physics may be, just letting them do their work would have entirely prevented these loops:
(56 / 4) = 14
frames to escape the
other bumper's hitbox. If the initial bounce reduces the Orb's Y
velocity far enough for it to not manage that distance the first time,
it will never reach the necessary speed again. In this loop, the
bounce-off force even stabilizes, though this doesn't have to happen.
The blue areas indicate the pixel-perfect* hitboxes of each bumper.
top
position always follows naturally
from its Y velocity and the force applied to it, and gravity wins out
in the end. The blue areas indicate the pixel-perfect* hitboxes of each bumper.
Now, you might be thinking that these Y assignments were just an attempt to prevent the Orb from colliding with the same bumper again on the next frame. After all, those 24 pixels exactly correspond to ⅓ of the height of a bumper's hitbox with an additional pixel added on top. However, the game already perfectly prevents repeated collisions by turning off collision testing with the same bumper for the next 7 frames after a collision. Thus, we can conclude that ZUN either explicitly coded bumper collision handling to facilitate these loops, or just didn't take out that code after inevitably discovering what it did. This is not janky code, it's not a glitch, it's not sarcasm from my end, and it's not the game's physics being bad.
But wait. Couldn't these assignments just be a remnant from a time in development before ZUN decided on the 7-frame delay on further collisions? Well, even that explanation stops holding water after the next few lines of code. Simplified, again:
pixel_t delta_x_between_orb_and_bumper = (orb.left - bumper.left); if((orb.velocity.x == +4) && (delta_x_between_orb_and_bumper < 0)) { orb.velocity.x = -4; } else if((orb.velocity.x == -4) && (delta_x_between_orb_and_bumper > 0)) { orb.velocity.x = +4; }
What's important here is the part that's not in the code – namely, anything that handles X velocities of -8 or +8. In those cases, the Orb simply continues in the same horizontal direction. The manual Y assignment is the only part of the code that actually prevents a collision there, as the newly applied force is not guaranteed to be enough:
Forgetting to handle ⅖ of your discrete X velocity cases is simply not something you do by accident. So we might as well say that ZUN deliberately designed the game to behave exactly as it does in this regard.
Bumpers also come in vertical or horizontal bar shapes. Their collision handling also turns off further collision testing for the next 7 frames, and doesn't do any manual coordinate assignment. That's definitely a step up in cleanliness from round bumpers, but it doesn't seem to keep in mind that the player can fire a new shot every 4 frames when standing still. That makes it immediately obvious why this works:
That's the most well-known case of reducing the Orb's horizontal velocity to 0 by exactly hitting it with shots in its center and then button-mashing it through a horizontal bar. This also works with vertical bars and yields even more interesting results there, but if we want to have any chance of understanding what happens there, we have to first go over some basics:
- Collision detection for all stage obstacles is done in row-major order from the top-left to the bottom-right corner of the playfield.
- All obstacles are collision-tested independently from each other, with the collision response code immediately following the test.
- The hitboxes for bumper bars extend far past their 32×32 sprites to make sure that the Orb can collide with them from any side. They are a pixel-perfect* 87×56 pixels for horizontal bars, and 57×87 pixels for vertical ones. Yes, that's no typo, they really do differ in one pixel.
- Changing the Y velocity during such a collision just involves applying a new force with the magnitude of the negated current Y velocity, which can be done multiple times during a frame without changing the result. This explains why the force is correctly inverted in the clip above, despite the Orb colliding with two bumpers simultaneously.
- Lacking a similar force system, the X coordinate is simply directly inverted.
However, if that were everything the game did, kicking the Orb into a column of vertical bumper bars would lead them to behave more like a rope that the Orb can climb, as the initial collision with two hitboxes cancels out the intended sign change that reflects the Orb away from the bars:
While the visualization reveals small sections where three hitboxes overlap, the Orb can never actually collide with three of them at the same time, as those 3-hitbox regions are 2 pixels smaller than they would need to be to fit the Orb. That's exactly the difference between using
<
rather than <=
in these hitbox
comparisons.
While that would have been a fun gameplay mechanic on its own, it immediately breaks apart once you place two vertical bumper bars next to each other. Due to how these bumper bar hitboxes extend past their sprites, any two adjacent vertical bars will end up with the exact same hitbox in absolute screen coordinates. Stage 17 on the 魔界/Makai route contains exactly such a layout:
ZUN's workaround: Setting a "vertical bumper bar block flag" after any
collision with such a bar, which simply disables any collision with
any vertical bar for the next 7 frames. This quick hack made all
vertical bars work as intended, and avoided the need for involving the Orb's
X velocity in any kind of physics system.
Edit (2022-07-12): This flag only works around glitches that would be caused by simultaneously colliding with more than one vertical bar. The actual response to a bumper bar collision still remains unaffected, and is very naive:
- Horizontal bars always invert the Orb's Y velocity
- Vertical bars invert either the Y or X velocity depending on whether the Orb's current X velocity is 0 (Y) or not (X)
Here's the hitbox overlay for
地獄/Jigoku Stage 19, and here's an updated
version of the 📝 Orb physics debug mod that
now also shows bumper bar collision frame numbers:
2022-07-10-TH01OrbPhysicsDebug.zip
See the th01_orb_debug
branch for the code. To use it, simply replace REIIDEN.EXE
, and
run the game in debug mode, via game d on the DOS prompt. If you
encounter a gameplay situation that doesn't seem to be covered by this blog
post, you can now verify it for yourself. Thanks to touhou-memories for bringing these
issues to my attention! That definitely was a glaring omission from the
initial version of this blog post.
With that clarified, we can now try mashing the Orb into these two vertical bars:
At first, that workaround doesn't seem to make a difference here. As we
expect, the frame numbers now tell us that only one of the two bumper bars
in a row activates, but we couldn't have told otherwise as the number of
bars has no effect on newly applied Y velocity forces. On a closer look, the
Orb's rise to the top of the playfield is in fact caused by that
workaround though, combined with the unchanged top-to-bottom order of
collision testing. As soon as any bumper bar completed its 7
collision delay frames, it resets the aforementioned flag, which already
reactivates collision handling for any remaining vertical bumper bars during
the same frame. Look out for frames with both a 7 and a 1, like the one marked in the video above:
The 7 will always appear before
the 1 in the row-major order. Whenever
this happens, the current oscillation period is cut down from 7 to 6
frames – and because collision testing runs from top to bottom, this will
always happen during the falling part. Depending on the Y velocity, the
rising part may also be cut down to 6 frames from time to time, but that one
at least has a chance to last for the full 7 frames. This difference
adds those crucial extra frames of upward movement, which add up to send the
Orb to the top. Without the flag, you'd always see the Orb oscillating
between a fixed range of the bar column.
Finally, it's the "top of playfield" force that gradually slows down the Orb
and makes sure it ultimately only moves at sub-pixel velocities, which have
no visible effect. Because
📝 the regular effect of gravity is reset with
each newly applied force, it's completely negated during most of the climb.
This even holds true once the Orb reached the top: Since the Orb requires a
negative force to repeatedly arrive up there and be bounced back, this force
will stay active for the first 5 of the 7 collision frames and not move the
Orb at all. Once gravity kicks in at the 5th frame and adds 1 to
the Y velocity, it's already too late: The new velocity can't be larger than
0.5, and the Orb only has 1 or 2 frames before the flag reset causes it to
be bounced back up to the top again.
Portals, on the other hand, turn out to be much simpler than the old description that ended up on Touhou Wiki in October 2005 might suggest. Everything about their teleportations is random: The destination portal, the exit force (as an integer between -9 and +9), as well as the exit X velocity, with each of the 📝 5 distinct horizontal velocities having an equal chance of being chosen. Of course, if the destination portal is next to the left or right edge of the playfield and it chooses to fire the Orb towards that edge, it immediately bounces off into the opposite direction, whereas the 0 velocity is always selected with a constant 20% probability.
The selection process for the destination portal involves a bit more than a
single rand()
call. The game bundles all obstacles in a single
structure of dynamically allocated arrays, and only knows how many obstacles
there are in total, not per type. Now, that alone wouldn't have much
of an impact on random portal selection, as you could simply roll a random
obstacle ID and try again if it's not a portal. But just to be extra cute,
ZUN instead iterates over all obstacles, selects any non-entered portal with
a chance of ¼, and just gives up if that dice roll wasn't successful after
16 loops over the whole array, defaulting to the entered portal in that
case.
In all its silliness though, this works perfectly fine, and results in a
chance of 0.7516(𝑛 - 1) for the Orb exiting out of the
same portal it entered, with 𝑛 being the total number of portals in a
stage. That's 1% for two portals, and 0.01% for three. Pretty decent for a
random result you don't want to happen, but that hurts nobody if it does.
The one tiny ZUN bug with portals is technically not even part of the newly
decompiled code here. If Reimu gets hit while the Orb is being sent through
a portal, the Orb is immediately kicked out of the portal it entered, no
matter whether it already shows up inside the sprite of the destination
portal. Neither of the two portal sprites is reset when this happens,
leading to "two Orbs" being visible simultaneously.
This makes very little sense no matter how you look at it. The Orb doesn't
receive a new velocity or force when this happens, so it will simply
re-enter the same portal once the gameplay resumes on Reimu's next life:
And that's it! At least the turrets don't have anything notable to say about them 📝 that I haven't said before.
That left another ½ of a push over at the end. Way too much time to finish
FUUIN.exe
, way too little time to start with Mima… but the bomb
animation fit perfectly in there. No secrets or bugs there, just a bunch of
sprite animation code wasting at least another 82 bytes in the data segment.
The special effect after the kuji-in sprites uses the same single-bitplane
32×32 square inversion effect seen at the end of Kikuri's and Sariel's
entrance animation, except that it's a 3-stack of 16-rings moving at 6, 7,
and 8 pixels per frame respectively. At these comparatively slow speeds, the
byte alignment of each square adds some further noise to the discoloration
pattern… if you even notice it below all the shaking and seizure-inducing
hardware palette manipulation.
And yes, due to the very destructive nature of the effect, the game does in
fact rely on it only being applied to VRAM page 0. While that will cause
every moving sprite to tear holes into the inverted squares along its
trajectory, keeping a clean playfield on VRAM page 1 is what allows all that
pixel damage to be easily undone at the end of this 89-frame animation.
Next up: Mima! Let's hope that stage obstacles already were the most complex part remaining in TH01…