Here we go, TH01 Sariel! This is the single biggest boss fight in all of
PC-98 Touhou: If we include all custom effect code we previously decompiled,
it amounts to a total of 10.31% of all code in TH01 (and 3.14%
overall). These 8 pushes cover the final 8.10% (or 2.47% overall),
and are likely to be the single biggest delivery this project will ever see.
Considering that I only managed to decompile 6.00% across all games in 2021,
2022 is already off to a much better start!
So, how can Sariel's code be that large? Well, we've got:
16 danmaku patterns; including the one snowflake detonating into a giant
94×32 hitbox
Gratuitous usage of floating-point variables, bloating the binary thanks
to Turbo C++ 4.0J's particularly horrid code generation
The hatching birds that shoot pellets
3 separate particle systems, sharing the general idea, overall code
structure, and blitting algorithm, but differing in every little detail
The "gust of wind" background transition animation
5 sets of custom monochrome sprite animations, loaded from
BOSS6GR?.GRC
A further 3 hardcoded monochrome 8×8 sprites for the "swaying leaves"
pattern during the second form
In total, it's just under 3,000 lines of C++ code, containing a total of 8
definite ZUN bugs, 3 of them being subpixel/pixel confusions. That might not
look all too bad if you compare it to the
📝 player control function's 8 bugs in 900 lines of code,
but given that Konngara had 0… (Edit (2022-07-17):
Konngara contains two bugs after all: A
📝 possible heap corruption in test or debug mode,
and the infamous
📝 temporary green discoloration.)
And no, the code doesn't make it obvious whether ZUN coded Konngara or
Sariel first; there's just as much evidence for either.
Some terminology before we start: Sariel's first form is separated
into four phases, indicated by different background images, that
cycle until Sariel's HP reach 0 and the second, single-phase form
starts. The danmaku patterns within each phase are also on a cycle,
and the game picks a random but limited number of patterns per phase before
transitioning to the next one. The fight always starts at pattern 1 of phase
1 (the random purple lasers), and each new phase also starts at its
respective first pattern.
Sariel's bugs already start at the graphics asset level, before any code
gets to run. Some of the patterns include a wand raise animation, which is
stored in BOSS6_2.BOS:
The "lowered wand" sprite is missing in this file simply because it's
captured from the regular background image in VRAM, at the beginning of the
fight and after every background transition. What I previously thought to be
📝 background storage code has therefore a
different meaning in Sariel's case. Since this captured sprite is fully
opaque, it will reset the entire 128×128 wand area… wait, 128×128, rather
than 96×96? Yup, this lowered sprite is larger than necessary, wasting 1,967
bytes of conventional memory. That still doesn't quite explain the
second sprite in BOSS6_2.BOS though. Turns out that the black
part is indeed meant to unblit the purple reflection (?) in the first
sprite. But… that's not how you would correctly unblit that?
The first sprite already eats up part of the red HUD line, and the second
one additionally fails to recover the seal pixels underneath, leaving a nice
little black hole and some stray purple pixels until the next background
transition. Quite ironic given that both
sprites do include the right part of the seal, which isn't even part of the
animation.
Just like Konngara, Sariel continues the approach of using a single function
per danmaku pattern or custom entity. While I appreciate that this allows
all pattern- and entity-specific state to be scoped locally to that one
function, it quickly gets ugly as soon as such a function has to do more than one thing.
The "bird function" is particularly awful here: It's just one if(…)
{…} else if(…) {…} else if(…) {…} chain with different
branches for the subfunction parameter, with zero shared code between any of
these branches. It also uses 64-bit floating-point double as
its subpixel type… and since it also takes four of those as parameters
(y'know, just in case the "spawn new bird" subfunction is called), every
call site has to also push four double values onto the stack.
Thanks to Turbo C++ even using the FPU for pushing a 0.0 constant, we
have already reached maximum floating-point decadence before even having
seen a single danmaku pattern. Why decadence? Every possible spawn position
and velocity in both bird patterns just uses pixel resolution, with no
fractional component in sight. And there goes another 720 bytes of
conventional memory.
Speaking about bird patterns, the red-bird one is where we find the first
code-level ZUN bug: The spawn cross circle sprite suddenly disappears after
it finished spawning all the bird eggs. How can we tell it's a bug? Because
there is code to smoothly fly this sprite off the playfield, that
code just suddenly forgets that the sprite's position is stored in Q12.4
subpixels, and treats it as raw screen pixels instead.
As a result, the well-intentioned 640×400
screen-space clipping rectangle effectively shrinks to 38×23 pixels in the
top-left corner of the screen. Which the sprite is always outside of, and
thus never rendered again.
The intended animation is easily restored though:
Also, did you know that birds actually have a quite unfair 14×38-pixel
hitbox? Not that you'd ever collide with them in any of the patterns…
Another 3 of the 8 bugs can be found in the symmetric, interlaced spawn rays
used in three of the patterns, and the 32×32 debris "sprites" shown at their endpoint, at
the edge of the screen. You kinda have to commend ZUN's attention to detail
here, and how he wrote a lot of code for those few rapidly animated pixels
that you most likely don't
even notice, especially with all the other wrong pixels
resulting from rendering glitches. One of the bugs in the very final pattern
of phase 4 even turns them into the vortex sprites from the second pattern
in phase 1 during the first 5 frames of
the first time the pattern is active, and I had to single-step the blitting
calls to verify it.
It certainly was annoying how much time I spent making sense of these bugs,
and all weird blitting offsets, for just a few pixels… Let's look at
something more wholesome, shall we?
So far, we've only seen the PC-98 GRCG being used in RMW (read-modify-write)
mode, which I previously
📝 explained in the context of TH01's red-white HP pattern.
The second of its three modes, TCR (Tile Compare Read), affects VRAM reads
rather than writes, and performs "color extraction" across all 4 bitplanes:
Instead of returning raw 1bpp data from one plane, a VRAM read will instead
return a bitmask, with a 1 bit at every pixel whose full 4-bit color exactly
matches the color at that offset in the GRCG's tile register, and 0
everywhere else. Sariel uses this mode to make sure that the 2×2 particles
and the wind effect are only blitted on top of "air color" pixels, with
other parts of the background behaving like a mask. The algorithm:
Set the GRCG to TCR mode, and all 8 tile register dots to the air
color
Read N bits from the target VRAM position to obtain an N-bit mask where
all 1 bits indicate air color pixels at the respective position
AND that mask with the alpha plane of the sprite to be drawn, shifted to
the correct start bit within the 8-pixel VRAM byte
Set the GRCG to RMW mode, and all 8 tile register dots to the color that
should be drawn
Write the previously obtained bitmask to the same position in VRAM
Quite clever how the extracted colors double as a secondary alpha plane,
making for another well-earned good-code tag. The wind effect really doesn't deserve it, though:
ZUN calculates every intermediate result inside this function
over and over and over again… Together with some ugly
pointer arithmetic, this function turned into one of the most tedious
decompilations in a long while.
This gradual effect is blitted exclusively to the front page of VRAM,
since parts of it need to be unblitted to create the illusion of a gust of
wind. Then again, anything that moves on top of air-colored background –
most likely the Orb – will also unblit whatever it covered of the effect…
As far as I can tell, ZUN didn't use TCR mode anywhere else in PC-98 Touhou.
Tune in again later during a TH04 or TH05 push to learn about TDW, the final
GRCG mode!
Speaking about the 2×2 particle systems, why do we need three of them? Their
only observable difference lies in the way they move their particles:
Up or down in a straight line (used in phases 4 and 2,
respectively)
Left or right in a straight line (used in the second form)
Left and right in a sinusoidal motion (used in phase 3, the "dark
orange" one)
Out of all possible formats ZUN could have used for storing the positions
and velocities of individual particles, he chose a) 64-bit /
double-precision floating-point, and b) raw screen pixels. Want to take a
guess at which data type is used for which particle system?
If you picked double for 1) and 2), and raw screen pixels for
3), you are of course correct! Not that I'm implying
that it should have been the other way round – screen pixels would have
perfectly fit all three systems use cases, as all 16-bit coordinates
are extended to 32 bits for trigonometric calculations anyway. That's what,
another 1.080 bytes of wasted conventional memory? And that's even
calculated while keeping the current architecture, which allocates
space for 3×30 particles as part of the game's global data, although only
one of the three particle systems is active at any given time.
That's it for the first form, time to put on "Civilization
of Magic"! Or "死なばもろとも"? Or "Theme of 地獄めくり"? Or whatever SYUGEN is
supposed to mean…
… and the code of these final patterns comes out roughly as exciting as
their in-game impact. With the big exception of the very final "swaying
leaves" pattern: After 📝 Q4.4,
📝 Q28.4,
📝 Q24.8, and double variables,
this pattern uses… decimal subpixels? Like, multiplying the number by
10, and using the decimal one's digit to represent the fractional part?
Well, sure, if you really insist on moving the leaves in cleanly
represented integer multiples of ⅒, which is infamously impossible in IEEE
754. Aside from aesthetic reasons, it only really combines less precision
(10 possible fractions rather than the usual 16) with the inferior
performance of having to use integer divisions and multiplications rather
than simple bit shifts. And it's surely not because the leaf sprites needed
an extended integer value range of [-3276, +3276], compared to
Q12.4's [-2047, +2048]: They are clipped to 640×400 screen space
anyway, and are removed as soon as they leave this area.
This pattern also contains the second bug in the "subpixel/pixel confusion
hiding an entire animation" category, causing all of
BOSS6GR4.GRC to effectively become unused:
At least their hitboxes are what you would expect, exactly covering the
30×30 pixels of Reimu's sprite. Both animation fixes are available on the th01_sariel_fixes
branch.
After all that, Sariel's main function turned out fairly unspectacular, just
putting everything together and adding some shake, transition, and color
pulse effects with a bunch of unnecessary hardware palette changes. There is
one reference to a missing BOSS6.GRP file during the
first→second form transition, suggesting that Sariel originally had a
separate "first form defeat" graphic, before it was replaced with just the
shaking effect in the final game.
Speaking about the transition code, it is kind of funny how the… um,
imperative and concrete nature of TH01 leads to these 2×24
lines of straight-line code. They kind of look like ZUN rattling off a
laundry list of subsystems and raw variables to be reinitialized, making
damn sure to not forget anything.
Whew! Second PC-98 Touhou boss completely decompiled, 29 to go, and they'll
only get easier from here! 🎉 The next one in line, Elis, is somewhere
between Konngara and Sariel as far as x86 instruction count is concerned, so
that'll need to wait for some additional funding. Next up, therefore:
Looking at a thing in TH03's main game code – really, I have little
idea what it will be!
Now that the store is open again, also check out the
📝 updated RE progress overview I've posted
together with this one. In addition to more RE, you can now also directly
order a variety of mods; all of these are further explained in the order
form itself.
Didn't quite get to cover background rendering for TH05's Stage 1-5
bosses in this one, as I had to reverse-engineer two more fundamental parts
involved in boss background rendering before.
First, we got the those blocky transitions from stage tiles to bomb and
boss backgrounds, loaded from BB*.BB and ST*.BB,
respectively. These files store 16 frames of animation, with every bit
corresponding to a 16×16 tile on the playfield. With 384×368 pixels to be
covered, that would require 69 bytes per frame. But since that's a very odd
number to work with in micro-optimized ASM, ZUN instead stores 512×512
pixels worth of bits, ending up with a frame size of 128 bytes, and a
per-frame waste of 59 bytes. At least it was
possible to decompile the core blitting function as __fastcall
for once.
But wait, TH05 comes with, and loads, a bomb .BB file for every character,
not just for the Reimu and Yuuka bomb transitions you see in-game… 🤔
Restoring those unused stage tile → bomb image transition
animations for Mima and Marisa isn't that trivial without having decompiled
their actual bomb animation functions before, so stay tuned!
Interestingly though, the code leaves out what would look like the most
obvious optimization: All stage tiles are unconditionally redrawn
each frame before they're erased again with the 16×16 blocks, no matter if
they weren't covered by such a block in the previous frame, or are
going to be covered by such a block in this frame. The same is true
for the static bomb and boss background images, where ZUN simply didn't
write a .CDG blitting function that takes the dirty tile array into
account. If VRAM writes on PC-98 really were as slow as the games'
README.TXT files claim them to be, shouldn't all the
optimization work have gone towards minimizing them?
Oh well, it's not like I have any idea what I'm talking about here. I'd
better stop talking about anything relating to VRAM performance on PC-98…
Second, it finally was time to solve the long-standing confusion about all
those callbacks that are supposed to render the playfield background. Given
the aforementioned static bomb background images, ZUN chose to make this
needlessly complicated. And so, we have two callback function
pointers: One during bomb animations, one outside of bomb
animations, and each boss update function is responsible for keeping the
former in sync with the latter.
Other than that, this was one of the smoothest pushes we've had in a while;
the hardest parts of boss background rendering all were part of
📝 the last push. Once you figured out that
ZUN does indeed dynamically change hardware color #0 based on the current
boss phase, the remaining one function for Shinki, and all of EX-Alice's
background rendering becomes very straightforward and understandable.
Meanwhile, -Tom- told me about his plans to publicly
release 📝 his TH05 scripting toolkit once
TH05's MAIN.EXE would hit around 50% RE! That pretty much
defines what the next bunch of generic TH05 pushes will go towards:
bullets, shared boss code, and one
full, concrete boss script to demonstrate how it's all combined. Next up,
therefore: TH04's bullet firing code…? Yes, TH04's. I want to see what I'm
doing before I tackle the undecompilable mess that is TH05's bullet firing
code, and you all probably want readable code for that feature as
well. Turns out it's also the perfect place for Blue Bolt's
pending contributions.
Turns out that TH04's player selection menu is exactly three times as
complicated as TH05's. Two screens for character and shot type rather than
one, and a way more intricate implementation for saving and restoring the
background behind the raised top and left edges of a character picture
when moving the cursor between Reimu and Marisa. TH04 decides to backup
precisely only the two 256×8 (top) and 8×244 (left) strips behind the
edges, indicated in red in the picture
below.
These take up just 4 KB of heap memory… but require custom blitting
functions, and expanding this explicitly hardcoded approach to TH05's 4
characters would have been pretty annoying. So, rather than, uh, not
explicitly hardcoding it all, ZUN decided to just be lazy with the backup
area in TH05, saving the entire 640×400 screen, and thus spending 128 KB
of heap memory on this rather simple selection shadow effect.
So, this really wasn't something to quickly get done during the first half
of a push, even after already having done TH05's equivalent of this menu.
But since life is very busy right now, I also used the occasion to start
addressing another code organization annoyance: master.lib's single master.h header file.
Now that ReC98 is trying to develop (or at least mimic) a more
type-safe C++ foundation to model the PC-98 hardware, a pure C header
(with counter-productive C++ extensions) is becoming increasingly
unidiomatic. By moving some of the original assumptions about function
parameters into the type system, we can also reduce the reliance on its
Japanese-only documentation without having to translate it
It's quite bloated, with at least 2800 lines of code that
currently are #included into the vast majority of files, not
counting master.h's recursively included C standard library
headers. PC-98 Touhou only makes direct use of a rather small fraction of
its contents.
And finally, all the DOS/V compatibility definitions are especially
useless in the context of ReC98. As I've noted
📝 time and
📝 time again, porting PC-98 Touhou to
IBM-compatible DOS won't be easy, and MASTER_DOSV won't be
helping much. Therefore, my upstream version of ReC98 will never include
all of master.lib. There's no point in lengthening compile times for
everyone by default, and those will be getting quite noticeable
after moving to a full 16-bit build process.
(Actually, what retro system ports should rather be doing: Get rid
of master.lib's original ASM code, replace it with
readable, modern
C++, and then simply convert the optimized assembly output of modern
compilers to your ISA of choice. Improving the landscape of such
assembly or object file converters would benefit everyone!)
So, time to start a new master.hpp header that would contain
just the declarations from master.h that PC-98 Touhou
actually needs, plus some semantic (yes, semantic) sugar. Comparing just
the old master.h to just the new master.hpp
after roughly 60% of the transition has been completed, we get median
build times of 319 ms for master.h, and 144 ms for
master.hpp on my (admittedly rather slow) DOSBox setup.
Nice!
As of this push, ReC98 consists of 107 translation units that have to be
compiled with Turbo C++ 4.0J. Fully rebuilding all of these currently
takes roughly 37.5 seconds in DOSBox. After the transition to
master.hpp is done, we could therefore shave some 10 to 15
seconds off this time, simply by switching header files. And that's just
the beginning, as this will also pave the way for further
#include optimizations. Life in this codebase will be great!
Unfortunately, there wasn't enough time to repay some of the actual
technical debt I was looking forward to, after all of this. Oh well, at
least we now also have nice identifiers for the three different boldface
options that are used when rendering text to VRAM, after procrastinating
that issue for almost 11 months. Next up, assuming the existing
subscriptions: More ridiculous decompilations of things that definitely
weren't originally written in C, and a big blocker in TH03's
MAIN.EXE.
Back to TH01, and its boss sprite format… with a separate class for
storing animations that only differs minutely from the
📝 regular boss entity class I covered last time?
Decompiling this class was almost free, and the main reason why the first
of these pushes ended up looking pretty huge.
Next up were the remaining shape drawing functions from the code segment
that started with the .GRC functions. P0105 already started these with the
(surprisingly sanely implemented) 8×8 diamond, star, and… uh, snowflake
(?) sprites
,
prominently seen in the Konngara, Elis, and Sariel fights, respectively.
Now, we've also got:
ellipse arcs with a customizable angle distance between the individual
dots – mostly just used for drawing full circles, though
line loops – which are only used for the rotating white squares around
Mima, meaning that the white star in the YuugenMagan fight got a completely
redundant reimplementation
and the surprisingly weirdest one, drawing the red invincibility
sprites.
The weirdness becomes obvious with just a single screenshot:
First, we've got the obvious issue of the sprites not being clipped at the
right edge of VRAM, with the rightmost pixels in each row of the sprite
extending to the beginning of the next row. Well, that's just what you get
if you insist on writing unique low-level blitting code for the majority
of the individual sprites in the game… 🤷
More importantly though, the sprite sheet looks like this:
So how do we even get these fully filled red diamonds?
Well, turns out that the sprites are never consistently unblitted during
their 8 frames of animation. There is a function that looks
like it unblits the sprite… except that it starts with by enabling the
GRCG and… reading from the first bitplane on the background page?
If this was the EGC, such a read would fill some internal registers with
the contents of all 4 bitplanes, which can then subsequently be blitted to
all 4 bitplanes of any VRAM page with a single memory write. But with the
GRCG in RMW mode, reads do nothing special, and simply copy the memory
contents of one bitplane to the read destination. Maybe ZUN thought
that setting the RMW color to red
also sets some internal 4-plane mask register to match that color?
Instead, the rather random pixels read from the first bitplane are then
used as a mask for a second blit of the same red sprite.
Effectively, this only really "unblits" the invincibility pixels that are
drawn on top of Reimu's sprite. Since Reimu is drawn first, the
invincibility sprites are overwritten anyway. But due to the palette color
layout of Reimu's sprite, its pixels end up fully masking away any
invincibility sprite pixels in that second blit, leaving VRAM untouched as
a result. Anywhere else though, this animation quickly turns into the
union of all animation frames.
Then again, if that 16-dot-aligned rectangular unblitting function is all
you know about the EGC, and you can't be bothered to write a perfect
unblitter for 8×8 sprites, it becomes obvious why you wouldn't want to use
it:
Because Reimu would barely be visible under all that flicker. In
comparison, those fully filled diamonds actually look pretty good.
After all that, the remaining time wouldn't have been enough for the next
few essential classes, so I closed out the push with three more VRAM
effects instead:
Single-bitplane pixel inversion inside a 32×32 square – the main effect
behind the discoloration seen in the bomb animation, as well as the
expanding squares at the end of Kikuri's and Sariel's entrance
animation
EGC-accelerated VRAM row copies – the second half of smooth and fully
hardware-accelerated scrolling for backgrounds that are twice the size of
VRAM
And finally, the VRAM page content transition function using meshed 8×8
squares, used for the blocky transition to Sariel's first and second phases.
Which is quite ridiculous in just how needlessly bloated it is. I'm positive
that this sort of thing could have also been accelerated using the PC-98's
EGC… although simply writing better C would have already gone a long way.
The function also comes with three unused mesh patterns.
And with that, ReC98, as a whole, is not only ⅓ done, but I've also fully
caught up with the feature backlog for the first time in the history of
this crowdfunding! Time to go into maintenance mode then, while we wait
for the next pushes to be funded. Got a huge backlog of tiny maintenance
issues to address at a leisurely pace, and of course there's also the
📝 16-bit build system waiting to be
finished.