Technical debt, part 5… and we only got TH05's stupidly optimized
.PI functions this time?
As far as actual progress is concerned, that is. In maintenance news
though, I was really hyped for the #include improvements I've
mentioned in 📝 the last post. The result: A
new x86real.h file, bundling all the declarations specific to
the 16-bit x86 Real Mode in a smaller file than Turbo C++'s own
DOS.H. After all, DOS is something else than the underlying
CPU. And while it didn't speed up build times quite as much as I had hoped,
it now clearly indicates the x86-specific parts of PC-98 Touhou code to
future port authors.
After another couple of improvements to parameter declaration in ASM land,
we get to TH05's .PI functions… and really, why did ZUN write all of
them in ASM? Why (re)declare all the necessary structures and data in
ASM land, when all these functions are merely one layer of abstraction
above master.lib, which does all the actual work?
I get that ZUN might have wanted masked blitting to be faster, which is
used for the fade-in effect seen during TH05's main menu animation and the
ending artwork. But, uh… he knew how to modify master.lib. In fact, he
did already modify the graph_pack_put_8() function
used for rendering a single .PI image row, to ignore master.lib's VRAM
clipping region. For this effect though, he first blits each row regularly
to the invisible 400th row of VRAM, and then does an EGC-accelerated
VRAM-to-VRAM blit of that row to its actual target position with the mask
enabled. It would have been way more efficient to add another version of
this function that takes a mask pattern. No amount of REP
MOVSW is going to change the fact that two VRAM writes per line are
slower than a single one. Not to mention that it doesn't justify writing
every other .PI function in ASM to go along with it…
This is where we also find the most hilarious aspect about this: For most
of ZUN's pointless micro-optimizations, you could have maybe made the
argument that they do save some CPU cycles here and there, and
therefore did something positive to the final, PC-98-exclusive result. But
some of the hand-written ASM here doesn't even constitute a
micro-optimization, because it's worse than what you would have got
out of even Turbo C++ 4.0J with its 80386 optimization flags!
At least it was possible to "decompile" 6 out of the 10 functions
here, making them easy to clean up for future modders and port authors.
Could have been 7 functions if I also decided to "decompile"
pi_free(), but all the C++ code is already surrounded by ASM,
resulting in 2 ASM translation units and 2 C++ translation units.
pi_free() would have needed a single translation unit by
itself, which wasn't worth it, given that I would have had to spell out
every single ASM instruction anyway.
There you go. What about this needed to be written in ASM?!?
The function calls between these small translation units even seemed to
glitch out TASM and the linker in the end, leading to one CALL
offset being weirdly shifted by 32 bytes. Usually, TLINK reports a fixup
overflow error when this happens, but this time it didn't, for some reason?
Mirroring the segment grouping in the affected translation unit did solve
the problem, and I already knew this, but only thought of it after spending
quite some RTFM time… during which I discovered the -lE
switch, which enables TLINK to use the expanded dictionaries in
Borland's .OBJ and .LIB files to speed up linking. That shaved off roughly
another second from the build time of the complete ReC98 repository. The
more you know… Binary blobs compiled with non-Borland tools would be the
only reason not to use this flag.
So, even more slowdown with this 5th dedicated push, since we've still only
repaid 41% of the technical debt in the SHARED segment so far.
Next up: Part 6, which hopefully manages to decompile the FM and SSG
channel animations in TH05's Music Room, and hopefully ends up being the
final one of the slow ones.
Alright, back to continuing the master.hpp transition started
in P0124, and repaying technical debt. The last blog post already
announced some ridiculous decompilations… and in fact, not a single
one of the functions in these two pushes was decompilable into
idiomatic C/C++ code.
As usual, that didn't keep me from trying though. The TH04 and TH05
version of the infamous 16-pixel-aligned, EGC-accelerated rectangle
blitting function from page 1 to page 0 was fairly average as far as
unreasonable decompilations are concerned.
The big blocker in TH03's MAIN.EXE, however, turned out to be
the .MRS functions, used to render the gauge attack portraits and bomb
backgrounds. The blitting code there uses the additional FS and GS segment
registers provided by the Intel 386… which
are not supported by Turbo C++'s inline assembler, and
can't be turned into pointers, due to a compiler bug in Turbo C++ that
generates wrong segment prefix opcodes for the _FS and
_GS pseudo-registers.
Apparently I'm the first one to even try doing that with this compiler? I
haven't found any other mention of this bug…
Compiling via assembly (#pragma inline) would work around
this bug and generate the correct instructions. But that would incur yet
another dependency on a 16-bit TASM, for something honestly quite
insignificant.
What we can always do, however, is using __emit__() to simply
output x86 opcodes anywhere in a function. Unlike spelled-out inline
assembly, that can even be used in helper functions that are supposed to
inline… which does in fact allow us to fully abstract away this compiler
bug. Regular if() comparisons with pseudo-registers
wouldn't inline, but "converting" them into C++ template function
specializations does. All that's left is some C preprocessor abuse
to turn the pseudo-registers into types, and then we do retain a
normal-looking poke() call in the blitting functions in the
end. 🤯
Yeah… the result is
batshitinsane.
I may have gone too far in a few places…
One might certainly argue that all these ridiculous decompilations
actually hurt the preservation angle of this project. "Clearly, ZUN
couldn't have possibly written such unreasonable C++ code.
So why pretend he did, and not just keep it all in its more natural ASM
form?" Well, there are several reasons:
Future port authors will merely have to translate all the
pseudo-registers and inline assembly to C++. For the former, this is
typically as easy as replacing them with newly declared local variables. No
need to bother with function prolog and epilog code, calling conventions, or
the build system.
No duplication of constants and structures in ASM land.
As a more expressive language, C++ can document the code much better.
Meticulous documentation seems to have become the main attraction of ReC98
these days – I've seen it appreciated quite a number of times, and the
continued financial support of all the backers speaks volumes. Mods, on the
other hand, are still a rather rare sight.
Having as few .ASM files in the source tree as possible looks better to
casual visitors who just look at GitHub's repo language breakdown. This way,
ReC98 will also turn from an "Assembly project" to its rightful state
of "C++ project" much sooner.
And finally, it's not like the ASM versions are
gone – they're still part of the Git history.
Unfortunately, these pushes also demonstrated a second disadvantage in
trying to decompile everything possible: Since Turbo C++ lacks TASM's
fine-grained ability to enforce code alignment on certain multiples of
bytes, it might actually be unfeasible to link in a C-compiled object file
at its intended original position in some of the .EXE files it's used in.
Which… you're only going to notice once you encounter such a case. Due to
the slightly jumbled order of functions in the
📝 second, shared code segment, that might
be long after you decompiled and successfully linked in the function
everywhere else.
And then you'll have to throw away that decompilation after all 😕 Oh
well. In this specific case (the lookup table generator for horizontally
flipping images), that decompilation was a mess anyway, and probably
helped nobody. I could have added a dummy .OBJ that does nothing but
enforce the needed 2-byte alignment before the function if I
really insisted on keeping the C version, but it really wasn't
worth it.
Now that I've also described yet another meta-issue, maybe there'll
really be nothing to say about the next technical debt pushes?
Next up though: Back to actual progress
again, with TH01. Which maybe even ends up pushing that game over the 50%
RE mark?
Back to TH05! Thanks to the good funding situation, I can strike a nice
balance between getting TH05 position-independent as quickly as possible,
and properly reverse-engineering some missing important parts of the game.
Once 100% PI will get the attention of modders, the code will then be in
better shape, and a bit more usable than if I just rushed that goal.
By now, I'm apparently also pretty spoiled by TH01's immediate
decompilability, after having worked on that game for so long.
Reverse-engineering in ASM land is pretty annoying, after all,
since it basically boils down to meticulously editing a piece of ASM into
something I can confidently call "reverse-engineered". Most of the
time, simply decompiling that piece of code would take just a little bit
longer, but be massively more useful. So, I immediately tried decompiling
with TH05… and it just worked, at every place I tried!? Whatever the issue
was that made 📝 segment splitting so
annoying at my first attempt, I seem to have completely solved it in the
meantime. 🤷 So yeah, backers can now request pretty much any part of TH04
and TH05 to be decompiled immediately, with no additional segment
splitting cost.
(Protip for everyone interested in starting their own ReC project: Just
declare one segment per function, right from the start, then group them
together to restore the original code segmentation…)
Except that TH05 then just throws more of its infamous micro-optimized and
undecompilable ASM at you. 🙄 This push covered the function that adjusts
the bullet group template based on rank and the selected difficulty,
called every time such a group is configured. Which, just like pretty
much all of TH05's bullet spawning code, is one of those undecompilable
functions. If C allowed labels of other functions as goto
targets, it might have been decompilable into something useful to
modders… maybe. But like this, there's no point in even trying.
This is such a terrible idea from a software architecture point of view, I
can't even. Because now, you suddenly have to mirror your C++
declarations in ASM land, and keep them in sync with each other. I'm
always happy when I get to delete an ASM declaration from the codebase
once I've decompiled all the instances where it was referenced. But for
TH05, we now have to keep those declarations around forever. 😕 And all
that for a performance increase you probably couldn't even measure. Oh
well, pulling off Galaxy Brain-level ASM optimizations is kind of
fun if you don't have portability plans… I guess?
If I started a full fangame mod of a PC-98 Touhou game, I'd base it on
TH04 rather than TH05, and backport selected features from TH05 as
needed. Just because it was released later doesn't make it better, and
this is by far not the only one of ZUN's micro-optimizations that just
went way too far.
Dropping down to ASM also makes it easier to introduce weird quirks.
Decompiled, one of TH05's tuning conditions for
stack
groups on Easy Mode would look something like:
case BP_STACK:
// […]
if(spread_angle_delta >= 2) {
stack_bullet_count--;
}
The fields of the bullet group template aren't typically reset when
setting up a new group. So, spread_angle_delta in the context
of a stack group effectively refers to "the delta angle of the last
spread group that was fired before this stack – whenever that was".
uth05win also spotted this quirk, considered it a bug, and wrote
fanfiction by changing spread_angle_delta to
stack_bullet_count.
As usual for functions that occur in more than one game, I also decompiled
the TH04 bullet group tuning function, and it's perfectly sane, with no
such quirks.
In the more PI-focused parts of this push, we got the TH05-exclusive
smooth boss movement functions, for flying randomly or towards a given
point. Pretty unspectacular for the most part, but we've got yet another
uth05win inconsistency in the latter one. Once the Y coordinate gets close
enough to the target point, it actually speeds up twice as much as the
X coordinate would, whereas uth05win used the same speedup factors for
both. This might make uth05win a couple of frames slower in all boss
fights from Stage 3 on. Hard to measure though – and boss movement partly
depends on RNG anyway.
Next up: Shinki's background animations – which are actually the single
biggest source of position dependence left in TH05.
The glacial pace continues, with TH05's unnecessarily, inappropriately
micro-optimized, and hence, un-decompilable code for rendering the current
and high score, as well as the enemy health / dream / power bars. While
the latter might still pass as well-written ASM, the former goes to such
ridiculous levels that it ends up being technically buggy. If you
enjoy quality ZUN code, it's
definitely worth a read.
In TH05, this all still is at the end of code segment #1, but in TH04,
the same code lies all over the same segment. And since I really
wanted to move that code into its final form now, I finally did the
research into decompiling from anywhere else in a segment.
Turns out we actually can! It's kinda annoying, though: After splitting
the segment after the function we want to decompile, we then need to group
the two new segments back together into one "virtual segment" matching the
original one. But since all ASM in ReC98 heavily relies on being
assembled in MASM mode, we then start to suffer from MASM's group
addressing quirk. Which then forces us to manually prefix every single
function call
from inside the group
to anywhere else within the newly created segment
with the group name. It's stupidly boring busywork, because of all the
function calls you mustn't prefix. Special tooling might make this
easier, but I don't have it, and I'm not getting crowdfunded for it.
So while you now definitely can request any specific thing in any
of the 5 games to be decompiled right now, it will take slightly
longer, and cost slightly more.
(Except for that one big segment in TH04, of course.)
Only one function away from the TH05 shot type control functions now!